Posted by Emmo on October 23, 2008
Since the days of its first release, International Superstar Soccer for the SNES, The great debate has always been about who was best? Konami’s ISS or EA’s Fifa? For the last 12 years Konami have (just about) held that title.
The History Of The Battle: EA Vs Konami:
EA’s Fifa started in 1994 on the Mega Drive II and it was simply titled Fifa 94
Playstation arrived and saw Fifa go to a new level but most still preferred Konami’s offering.
I have several mates who all preferred ISS to Fifa. Yes Fifa has all the real kits and player names but ISS had the game play whereas Fifa’s felt emotionless. You could score easy in Fifa – just pick Real Madrid, get the ball to Laudrup and watch him run unchallenged to score another goal in a 13-0 victory. Fifa was all about spectacular goals and not about game play. In ISS you had to think about your passes and time them right as you edged the game by the odd goal. When you scored in ISS you really felt like you had achieved something after all goals win games but not all are scored by flipping the ball over the defenders head and belting it in the top corner like Fifa would have you believe happened for every goal in every game.
As the years passed and countless games were released Konami had the edge – the now titled Pro Evolution Soccer was the victor in the battle with EA’s dour titled and poor game play in FIFA.
Then something happened in late 2005. That something was called Next Generation consoles (360 & PS3). EA had made a game for these consoles using the powerful machines whereas Konami hadn’t. In fact their first release on the NG console was Pro Evolution Soccer 6 which was awful (no edit modes) and EA still not quite as good as Evo was slowly gaining in play ability. Konami had said the game wasn’t Next Generation and had been made based on the PS2 model. They also admitted it had been rushed to compete with Fifa (both games are always released within 2 weeks of each other) If that was the case they should have waited.
In 2007 Konami released Pro Evo 2008 which again was rushed but played OK (if a little too fast) but still wasn’t making full use of the next gen consoles. Fifa 08 was and got the play ability pretty much spot on. Now EA had added game play to the full licences Konami was left red faced as most diehard fans defected to Fifa.
Which brings us nicely onto Pro Evolution Soccer 2009.
Pro Evo 2009:
As soon as the game comes on the intro is impressive but the menus are ugly and dated. Big and blocky and just a mess in general. Konami don’t seem to care or are totally oblivious to the fact that EA have over taken them this year (FIFA09 has the game play that Konami once had if not better). Fans of Pro Evo used to accept that most of the real team names wouldn’t be correct especially from the Premier League (only Liverpool and Man U are official this year) but at least they had the real Italian, German and Spanish names. Not anymore. Konami now only have 4 official teams from each league and have ditched the German teams altogether.
Not only do the teams not have the real names they no longer have the real kits either. For example Atletico Madrid don’t play in the Red and White stripes with blue shorts but play in total Green? Yes the full edit mode is back but I don’t have time to change over 200 team names and kits. Nor do I want to play with Teeside for example.
The normal leagues and cups are there all without the proper names. The Premier League is called the English League and the league cups are called Konami cups.
New Features:
Getting past the menus Konami have secured the full licence to the Champions League which does look good. Choose a team in this year’s CL and take them to glory. But in typical Konami fashion its half baked as although the CL License is in full not all the teams are. Taking London FC to the final isnt quite the same as taking Chelsea is it? Also during Pro Evo’s world famous Master League mode (create a team with rubbish players and earn points to buy better players) you can qualify for the CL, only it’s not called the CL in Master League mode it’s called European Championship and won’t have the trimmings of the CL mode. Why bother to get the CL licence if you won’t put it in the Master League? It’s another sign that Konami are resting on past glories.
They have also added a new feature called Become A Legend where you take charge of only 1 player (midfielder or forward) during the game and see the game through your eyes. The idea is to err… become a legend. You start of at your hometown club and play 1 game. After that game 3 teams (not big teams) will come in for you and you choose one and start playing in practice matches you aim to get on the bench, in the starting 11, then leave for a bigger club et etc until you’re the best player in the world. It’s a bit of fun but Konami should have spent more effort in other areas. Footie fans will also remember a game in the 90s called Lebo Grande which was the same thing so it’s nothing new.
Master League:
The Master League is untouched for the roughly the 6th year running. Some would say that’s a good thing but there are still a few glitches. Like using points instead of money to buy players, no one is ever cup tied when you buy them and you always get teams from your division in your CL group, Sorry… European Championship group! Still, creating your own team from scratch and taking them from the bottom to the top makes a great game it just needs a little modernising.
Players & Stats:
Now I appreciate that it must take time to create over 3000 players putting in each statistic but if you are going to do it at least do it properly. For example Liverpool’s Fernando Torres scored 33 goals in 40 odd games last season yet his stats have gone down from Evo 07. Keeper Pepe Riena has been given 72/100 for goal keeping stats yet has the most clean sheets in the league over the last 3 seasons. To prove I’m not being biased towards Liverpool’s players, Arsenal’s Bacary Sagna was one of the best defenders in the league last season and won rave reviews yet Konami only rate him as 68/100. Funnily enough the South Asian players (where the game is made) have stats that defy belief. Regarding transfers Berbatov is still at Spurs and so too is Malbranque. Robihno is still at Madrid. These transfers happened on the last day of the transfer window which was 01/09/08 – giving Konami 6 weeks to put the players in their new teams but they haven’t bothered. EA done it so why couldn’t Konami?
Game Play:
Now the game play. This is really important to Konami as it is the game play which has kept Pro Evo at the top of the charts. At first the game loads up and looks impressive but when the game starts that’s when you finally get the hump. It’s been slowed down from last year’s release and that’s a good thing but not when fast players look like they are running through treacle and don’t seem to get anywhere. The players seem to bunch in the middle of the field and they are joined by the ref so it looks a one big bundle in the centre of the park. Shooting is more difficult than previous versions which is fine but would a forward blast over from 6 yards every time? I wouldn’t have thought so. Keepers since Evo 06 haven’t been able to hold onto shots and nothing has changed in that sense. One minute they are pulling of world class saves only to parry the softest of shots into the path of a forward for an easy tap in the next. Passing has improved and players will point to where they want the ball which is a nice touch. You can still run your centre half from one end of the field to the other unchallenged which was a major flaw in the last 2 versions. Refs are as fussy as ever with the first foul of the game often resulting in a caution or red card. The in game graphics are OK but are not NG standard as the players are not flexible and seem robot like. It may be windy and raining but their shorts don’t move in the wind or when they run. Players can only turn in 8 directions which makes a submarine turning seem quick. This might be a bit anal but the goal nets are annoying. Not only are they the same at every ground (even Wembley) so you can’t tell what stadium you are at, but even when you tap the ball into an open goal the ball pings around the net like a pinball. They may have the official Liverpool and Man U teams but there is no Anfield or Old toilet – sorry Old Trafford to play your home games at.
So all in all not a great deal of improvement from last season it’s just been slowed down.
Online Play:
I have played 3 games online and only 1 has been playable due to serious lag. Just getting a game started online is time consuming and has taken me up to 15 minutes. In my first game I lost 0-5 but for 3 of those goals my player had the ball, the picture froze and when it came back the opposition had smacked the ball into the net. Also players teleport. They are there one minute but not the next only to re-appear at the other end of the pitch. Keepers seem to run out for the ball but don’t dive at the players feet so annoying gaols are conceded. Konami say they will be fixing broken servers every night but the lag really needs to be looked at.
Summary:
The question is this….Have Konami learned their lesson or noticed they have lost fans to Fifa and brought out the most amazing game their loyal fan base deserves? In a word the answer is a big fat NO. The reason for this is simple. Pro Evo 2009 is still not a Next Gen game. OK its available on the next gen consoles but that’s it.
I really wanted this game to be brilliant especially after the last few versions but it’s not. I can’t decide whether the game has gone backwards or just stood still. I think it’s probably a bit of both. Konami have won the battle V’s EA for 12 years but have lost the 12 year war. It’s the first time I have played a Pro Evo game and not felt excited by it. As a fan of Pro Evo I accept that there will be no licences and real players names but now they have not put most teams in their correct colours, made the game Next Gen or really improved the game play I (and many others) have finally had enough. Pro Evo’s 1-5 were brilliant but with 6 being the first 360 release and being such a disappointment Konami have had another 2 versions to get it right but they haven’t. They are releasing substandard games due to complacency. If someone like me, a PES Fan boy, prefers FIFA this year to Pro Evo 2009 then how many more will feel the same? FIFA have this year finally got the game play perfect. It’s taken them since 1994 but they have tried over the years to match Pro Evo and when they did they then wanted to overtake Konami and have. Konami really need to go back to the drawing board and start again from scratch. They need to remember why people bought them instead of EA in the first place. Pro Evo fans are not fussed about real kits and names but they need and deserve great game play to make up for it and that is missing from Pro Evo 2009. Yes I can buy a transfer data kit for £10 and have all but Premiership real names from option files available on the net, but why should I after already forking out £34 for the game? Now the game play isn’t there it doesn’t really matter.
Humberside Orange V North London Red anyone? Thought not……….
Rating:
5/10 – Go buy FIFA09 and play real football.
Posted under
Games,
Other Stuff